Following the information on threats to internal validity, the student provided suggestions regarding how these threats could have been dealt with. In-text citations should be made using the author-date system, which means that you only need to indicate name of the author, followed by the year of publication. Without these, it is impossible to evaluate the potential meaningfulness of this study. Your overall conclusions about the article base off on your own judgment backed up by your experience in this field and your common sense. Is it absolutely clear or too complicated for immediate understanding? You can only write a solid article review if you have made sure that you understand everything there is to understand in and about the article. Instead, make notes on the margins and draw connections between different parts of the article. In previous classes we spent more time talking about statistics than the literature review.
What was the purpose of the specific data? You should address both the positive and negative aspects. Give 1 relevant background 2 explain why the work was done 3 summarize results and explain the method. It is about how relevant and important the article under review is. Are there any troubles caused by the language of the article? These may be statistical tests name them or an ethnography, content analysis, grounded theory, etc for qualitative methods. The socioeconomics and population of the school itself could play a factor. You can also make a suggestion as to the direction for further research on the topic. Not only does the student know what the weakness of the study are, he provides ways the study could have been improved.
Scales were administered in a number of environmental settings: classrooms, gymnasiums, practice fields, and offices. This should include the author's claim, the conducted research, and the argument s. Generally, it is an objective analysis of any piece of work not depending on its genre , which includes your personal thoughts on the subject. The researchers submitted two hypotheses. Provide the general information about the article that you are reviewing.
When answering the question of what is an article review, you must understand the depth of analysis and evaluation that your instructor is seeking. An author has to adhere to maximal objectivity in their essay and always keep in mind that any article critique example is only a personal opinion of an attentive viewer, not a dogma of some kind. Then put together the lists of strong points and drawbacks and summarize them. What limitations were reported by the researcher. If the program has had several losing seasons in a row, perhaps the attitude of the coach could be different than that of a coach who has recently won a state title. Use the formal style and narrate impersonally or from the third person, avoid the first person.
Research Critique 1 Jamber, E. Check with your summary and describe how well the topic is covered in the article. Good summary of where this fits into the literature Maybe should give more background for someone not familiar with the area. A sampling of comments from Paper Presentation Critiques A sampling of comments from Paper Presentation Critiques Econ 730, Fall 2005 Problem statement: The research problem is clear; objectives clearly stated Research problem: why is it important? Usually, you will be required to talk about each of the article's main points separately and describe how well the given evidence supports them. Critique the Article Present the strengths and weaknesses that you have found in the article. Certain schools have better athletes and programs in a particular sport, while others may not be able to field a winning team.
Have to increase the dosage enough to control the suffering, but also not so much as to hasten death. This site offers review guidelines for a menu of article types, and it is an excellent, comprehensive resource to focus your study critique. Clear, but sometimes fell into trap of reading from slides. What were the results of the study? Very well organized; easy to understand Lecture style was slow; keep some enthusiasm It is very distracting when you click your pen throughout the pres. A larger sample with regard to all categories would have aided in the data analysis, particularly when looking for possible interactions between gender and coaching level. High school coaches scored much higher than college level coaches in democratic behavior.
Coaching experience would greatly effect the responses of the participants, yet this was not considered in the study. Establish the Significance of the Research Finally, it is important to establish whether the research has been successful — has it led to new questions being asked, new ways of using existing knowledge? Therefore, knowing how to critique an article, you should master the ability to compare your work with other pieces of critical writing — and only in this way you can reach the highest level in your profession. Following the above approach, while utilizing the resources available, will lay the groundwork for an outstanding presentation. Only Qualified Specialists Article Critique Example One of the ways of simplifying the whole process of completing the assignment is using an article critique example. What population was the sample representative of? Too many results on one slide Don't expect people to have a copy of the paper in their hands. That is why it is so simple to make one of many mistakes, while completing an article critique.
How did the researcher collect the sample? If certain aspects relate to your argument specifically, then make sure to include them. Make sure to articulate what your review is about in the first paragraph of your essay. Point out the possible gaps of information, logical inconsistencies, the contradiction of ideas, unanswered questions, etc. This may be either something you have discussed at school or something you have read on your own. Select a review article on a topic that interests you and that is written clearly so you can understand it. You do not perform any new research yourself.
What kind of data can be obtained using each technique? Bioscience 41 4 , 248-250. However, due to the nonrandom nature of the sample, the results would not generalizable beyond the 162 participants in the study. Does the study reveal what the researcher intended? Is all the material organized under the appropriate headings? That way, after reading the first paragraph, the reader would know the purpose, hypotheses, and findings. Should explain which factors affect positively or negatively on. An additional set of questions regarding the personal history of the coach in question could have helped reduce many of these threats. It also may be helpful to discuss data supporting the current standard of care against which the study intervention is being measured. Take this opportunity to verbally and graphically highlight key results from the study, with plans to expand on their significance later in your presentation.
Pay special attention to typing and spelling errors, grammar and punctuation, and — of course — the factual data. If the object of the study is a fictional book - what role can it play in the worldview of the potential reader? You can , avoiding its writing on your own to achieve a matchless result. How do you then put all this information together? Maybe show a table or two of results instead of just having a sentence on the findings. The goal of assigning article reviews is to get the students familiar with the works of the renowned specialists in a particular field. Does the writer understand completely the main purpose of the work? You also assess the new knowledge that the author has brought to the discipline and its application potential. Mention the reason why chose this paper; There was hardly any discussion of why this paper was selected until the end of the presentation. More intuition with less math.